Ask three outfits how to clear the same five acres. One wants to mulch it. One wants to push it into a pile and burn it. One wants to haul every stick away. All three can be right, each on different ground.
We own a mulching head and a dozer, plus an excavator and a root grapple. Mulch it or push it, the machine is ours either way. So we have no reason to sell you one method. Here is what each does, what it leaves and where it is the wrong tool.
One thing first. Only two of the four take growth off the land: shredding it, or pushing it over and digging it out. Burning and hauling are what happens to the pile afterward. Mulching makes no pile.
The four side by side
| Compared on | Forestry mulching | Bulldoze and grub | Pile and burn | Haul off |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| How it works | A drum of teeth shreds brush and small trees where they stand. | Trees are pushed over or dug out, roots and all. | The pile is left to dry, then burned on site. | The pile is loaded and trucked away. |
| What it leaves | A layer of mulch over soil nobody dug. | Bare dirt, rough graded, and a pile. | Ash and whatever did not burn. | Bare dirt and no pile. |
| Stumps and roots | Stay in the ground. The head works at ground level. | Come out. | Burn only if they were dug out first. | Leave only if they were dug out first. |
| Soil and erosion | Covered. Mulch helps reduce erosion. | Turned over and exposed. Topsoil is often lost. | The bare ground the pushing left. | The bare ground the pushing left. |
| Regrowth | The roots are alive, so sprouts come back. | A dug stump cannot sprout. Seeds in bare dirt can. | Changes nothing. | Changes nothing. |
| Price direction | The lowest of the three. One machine. | About double on a single acre. | No truck and no dump fee. | Added on top. You pay for every load. |
| Weather and law | Wants dry ground. No burn authorization, because nothing burns. | Wants dry ground. Leaves a pile to deal with. | Dry piles, the right wind, a state authorization that day. | No fire rules. Demolition debris cannot burn, so it leaves this way. |
Bottom lineIf nothing will be built, dug or plowed there, mulch it. Where a pad, a driveway or a plow is going, the stumps come out. Then the only question is the pile: leave it, burn it or haul it.
Forestry mulching: shredded where it stands
Our John Deere 335P track loader carries a John Deere MK76 mulching head: a steel drum with rows of carbide teeth. Privet, vines, briars and small trees go in standing and come out as chips. That is forestry mulching.
The soil is never dug. Virginia Cooperative Extension calls mulching an excellent way to keep or even build soil organic matter and reduce erosion. No pile, no fire, no truck. When the loader goes back on the trailer, the job is done. Our Thomasville job shows the ground it leaves.
Where mulching falls short
- The stumps stay. The head works at ground level and does not pull roots. Under a pad or a driveway they still have to be dug out.
- It grows back. University of Florida extension says cut privet sends up sprouts that need herbicide. Mimosa can sprout back three feet or more in one season. Plan on mowing or bush hogging.
- Big timber is not mulcher work. John Deere rates the MK76 for vegetation up to 8 inches thick.
- More mulch is not better. University of California extension reports fewer kinds of plants where the chips lie deeper than 4 inches.
- Mulch is still fuel. Oregon State extension notes it can make a ground fire burn hotter for a while. Mulching does not fireproof a lot.
- Wet or rocky ground. Extension guidance is to run the machine on dry soil. Very rocky sites do not suit a mulching head.
Bulldozing and grubbing: stumps and roots out
Trees are pushed over or dug out, root ball and all. The trade calls that grubbing. We dig each stump with the John Deere 60P excavator and lift it with its hydraulic thumb. Across open acres and heavy timber, my John Deere 650P dozer pushes trees, stumps and brush into piles. You get open dirt with nothing left in it to rot under a slab or catch a plow. No other method gives you that. We call the job land clearing.

What you give up is topsoil. Virginia Cooperative Extension is blunt: dozer clearing is quick, and it nearly always destroys the topsoil. Around Quincy there is not much to lose. The Orangeburg soils mapped on the uplands here carry about seven inches of loamy sand. Yellowish red sandy clay loam, the red clay, starts about a foot down. Push the top into the pile and the grass has to start in the subsoil.
So we grub only the ground that needs it. Where the topsoil matters, the Blue Diamond root grapple carries debris to the pile, and the dirt falls back through its tines. Bare dirt needs a plan too. University of Florida extension warns that soil torn up by heavy equipment can invite invasive plants. Breaking up cogongrass roots can spread it.
Pile and burn: no truck, where it is legal
Where the land has room, fire makes a pile go away with no truck and no dump fee. It also asks the most of the weather and the law. The pile has to be dry. The wind has to be right. Somebody stays with the fire. And the state has to say yes for that day.
Florida: every land clearing pile burn needs an authorizationThe Florida Forest Service must authorize every land clearing pile burn.
For a home site (existing or planned, up to two family units) the pile must sit 300 feet from any occupied building that is not yours. It must also be 100 feet from a paved public road and 50 feet from woods or brush. For other development the distance from occupied buildings is 1,000 feet. Piles must be dry and attended at all times. You ask the local office on the day of the burn. For Gadsden, Leon and Jefferson counties that is the Tallahassee Forestry Center, (850) 681-5951. For Jackson County it is the Chipola Forestry Center, (850) 373-1801.
Sources
- Know the Law: Land Clearing Debris Burns with ACI (brochure) (opens in a new tab)Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services, Florida Forest Service
- Burn Authorizations (opens in a new tab)Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services, Florida Forest Service
- Steps to get a prescribed burning authorization in Florida (handout) (opens in a new tab)Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services, Florida Forest Service
Georgia: a machine piled burn still needs a permitGeorgia dropped the permit for hand piled leaves and limbs in 2021.
Debris piled by a machine still counts as land clearing and needs a burn permit from the Georgia Forestry Commission (opens in a new tab), (800) 428-7337. The permit is good only for the day it is issued. State rules put the fire at least 1,000 feet from any occupied structure unless the Environmental Protection Division approves less. Only plant growth may burn. Storm debris burns go through the Commission too. Some counties require an air curtain destructor, so ask when you call. The summer burn ban, May 1 to September 30, covers 54 counties. Decatur, Thomas, Dougherty and Lowndes are not on the list. Check with your city or county office for local burn rules.
Sources
- Burn Permits and Notifications (opens in a new tab)Georgia Forestry Commission
- Open Burning Rules for Georgia (opens in a new tab)Georgia Environmental Protection Division, Air Protection Branch
- Open Burning Rules for Georgia: Burn Types (opens in a new tab)Georgia Environmental Protection Division, Air Protection Branch
- Summer Open Burning Ban (opens in a new tab)Georgia Environmental Protection Division, Air Protection Branch
Hold those distances up against a house lot in town and burning is often out. On open acreage it often fits. Neither state lets you burn tires, plastics, household garbage or treated lumber. An old shed in the brush goes on a truck. And do not bury what is left. Virginia Cooperative Extension warns that a back filled burn hole can sink later.
Haul off: clean, and you pay by the load
Everything is loaded and trucked away. On a tight lot with neighbors on every side, hauling can be the only way to make stumps disappear. For a torn down building it is always the way. You pay for every load, so mulch the brush first. Then only trunks and stumps go on the truck.
What each one costs and how long it takes
| Method | Estimate range | What is in it |
|---|---|---|
| Forestry mulching, one acre | $2,100 to $3,150 | One machine. The mulch stays on the ground. |
| Stumps out, one acre | $4,400 to $7,150 | Two machines. Stumps dug, debris piled on your land, rough grade. |
| Burning the pile | No set price | Settled at the estimate. |
| Hauling the pile | About $400 to $750 a load | Loading, trucking and the dump fee. |
Brush and small trees on flat, dry ground near Quincy
Forestry mulching, one acre
Estimate range: $2,100 to $3,150
One machine. The mulch stays on the ground.
Stumps out, one acre
Estimate range: $4,400 to $7,150
Two machines. Stumps dug, debris piled on your land, rough grade.
Burning the pile
No set price
Settled at the estimate.
Hauling the pile
Estimate range: About $400 to $750 a load
Loading, trucking and the dump fee.
The figures our instant quote works from. Estimates until I have walked your land. The one fixed number is the $2,000 job minimum. The cost guide has the full tables.
For scale, one statewide Florida clearing company reports that across 241 jobs its median machine day covered one acre. Grubbing takes longer, because every stump is dug by itself. A burn waits on dry wood and a good day. I give you the day count for your land after I have seen it.
Which one for my land
An overgrown lot with trees worth keeping
Mulch it. I walk it with you and flag the oaks and pines that stay, and the 335P works around them. That is selective clearing. It runs at the mulching rate, with no extra line for protecting the keepers.
A building site
Grub the footprint: the pad, the driveway, the septic field. Mulch the rest of the lot and keep your shade. The pile is burned if the setbacks fit and hauled if they do not. Shaping the pad is site preparation.
A pasture that went to brush
If cattle will graze around the stumps, mulch it. Virginia Cooperative Extension says most pine stumps rot away in three to five years. Hardwood can take far longer. If a disk or a planter has to go through that soil this year, the stumps come out. Either way, mow it afterward or the brush comes back.
A storm mess
Hurricane Michael damaged almost 3 million acres of forest in Florida in October 2018. That is the Florida Forest Service figure, as the National Weather Service reports it. Storm timber is big wood lying flat. That is thumb and grapple work: the thumb on the 60P and the grapple on the 335P are built to pick it, sort it and pile it. Tops and broken brush can be mulched. Trunks are burned where the rules fit, or hauled.
Big timber
Mature pines and hardwoods are past what a mulching head is for. That is dozer work, and I do it with my own John Deere 650P. If the stand has value, talk to a consulting forester first. Virginia Cooperative Extension notes that good timber can sometimes be traded against the cost of clearing. I look at big timber in person before any number is promised.
